Quantum Mechanics post and replies
Return to the Quantum Mechanics thread
Login to post to this thread
Difficult or Hard? | |
---|---|
Dave San Marcos, Texas 441 Posts |
I'm teaching senior level quantum mechanics this semester, and it's been a fun class to teach. One of the reasons is that it's a subject that most students are not familiar with, and which is somewhat counterintuitive. While this makes it fun to teach, it can be difficult for students. I would like to hear from other students on this matter. Did you enjoy your quantum class? Was it easy or hard for you? Did you like the text you used, and what text was it? Feel free to make any comments you want. I will chime in where appropriate. Try not to become a man of success, but rather try to become a man of value -- Albert Einstein |
Replies to Difficult or Hard?
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | |
---|---|
suyog 1 Posts |
Hello Dave, |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | |
---|---|
atomcorrall 23 Posts |
"Noone understands QM".......attributed to Richard Feynman. |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | ||
---|---|---|
truth_quarke8e8 Ohio 3 Posts |
unfortunatly I will not be able to enjoy Qm until next spring semster. However, I actually already like it. While I have not been able to get into the math, due to just now getting the skills needed, I have read a few diffrent things about QM. I am a bit nervouse in that I generally like to conceptulize the topics on my head, which sometimes you can't do with quantum. I still think that I will enjoy it, as there are many strange and awsome things that I will be learning. I think it might help if you are just blunt with the students. Just say 'hey, this is quantum, there are things that just won't make sense, and you will just have to deal with it.' |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | ||
---|---|---|
Steve Sacramento, CA 7 Posts |
As some one who is just finishing senior level QM, I can say that, in terms of the joy of learning something that is totally new, it has been great. Very few subjects have tested my ability to truly learn like QM. Having said that, I find that sometimes my professor lost the class in the algebra. What I mean by this is the fact that a great deal of the derivations are very tricky and full of a number of algebraic steps that are less than obvious. Obviously these are important to the course, so the best cure that I can see is a well-organized lecture. If the algebra in the lecture is easy to follow, it makes it all so much better. The book we used, Liboff, was pretty good at this, although he did make a number of strange typos and logical jumps. The funniest part about this message is that by the time you realize that it doesn't say anything, it's too late for you to stop reading it. |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | |
---|---|
Steve Buckley 5 Posts |
I'm done now with my classes, and I'd say that the first of a two semester QM class was the more challenging of the two. Admittedly, the 3d spherical harmonics were intimidating from the second semester. |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | |
---|---|
Felix Lin 24 Posts |
One thing that I personally found helpful was taking a philosophy of physics course separate from my actual quantum mechanics course. (Such a course deals with the conceptual framework of physics, the different interpretations of relativity and quantum mechanics, and the standards applied to determine which interpretations are valid.) |
quantum text comments - | |
---|---|
Gary Society of Physics... 293 Posts |
..just thought I'd point out that if you have a comment about a particular quantum text, say Griffiths, you can also leave it in the textbook section of the Nucleus: Adjunct Professor of Physics, Editor of The Physics Teacher, and GWU SPS Chapter Advisor |
Re: Difficult or Hard? - | |
---|---|
Pmb 2 Posts |
I didn't find it that hard. It was a lot easier when my professor basically told me to stop trying to understand it (my words, not his) and understand that what we do in QM is to use the Schrodinger equation to make predictions about what we'll measure in the lab. It's basically a "shut up and calculate." When he told me this I immediately understood that I wasn't missing anything (which I thought I was) and that I really did get it. Physicist (currently disabled) |