APS Excellence in Physics Education Award
November 2019

Education Prize Logo
Science SPORE Prize
November 2011

NSF Logo
The Open Source Physics Project is supported by NSF DUE-0442581.

Velocity problem with the step size post and replies

Return to the Velocity problem with the step size thread
Login to post to this thread

The size of the step change the value for velocity?
Ismael Lozano
2 Posts

The tracker software is great, in our lab resulted very useful. I have a question regarding a problem with my data. I measure the speed of escape of fish larvae. I am following the fish with a mass point step by step. I noted that if i register the speed (v) with a step size of 1 the maximum speed of the fish is 25.5. But if a register the same sequence with a step size of 36 the maximum speed is 2.5. I use the same calibration stick. My question is: is the speed changing with the step size? am i doing something wrong? It supposed that the speed is the same. Thank you for your time. Congratulations for the software
P.d.: sorry for the english, i am a spanish speaker

Replies to The size of the step change the value for velocity?

Re: The size of the step change the value for velocity? -
Douglas Brown Avatar
Douglas Brown
339 Posts

Hello Ismael. Tracker estimates the instantaneous velocity at a given step n by calculating the average velocity between the previous step n-1 and the following step n+1: 

vx[n] = (x[n+1] - x[n-1]) / (t[n+1] - t[n-1])

This means that for objects moving with constant speed in a straight line the step size makes no difference, but for objects (like your fish) that dart around with rapidly changing velocities then the step size can make a huge difference. Basically, using a larger step size gives you average speeds over longer time periods which will always be slower than the fastest instantaneous speeds reached.

Bottom line: if you need to determine the maximum speeds reached by your fish, you should use a step size of 1.  Doug

Thank you very much! -
Ismael Lozano
2 Posts

Thanks for clear the situation, now make sense. The reason that i use a step size of 36 is for obtain swimming cruise. For the maximum speed i used a step size of 1. The problem arise when i was measuring the cruise speed and the fish made a burst (very quickly swim). I previously measured that burst and i noted the difference in v.  Thank you again!

OSP Projects:
Open Source Physics - EJS Modeling
Physlet Physics
Physlet Quantum Physics
STP Book