Who won the debate? post and replies

Return to the Who won the debate? thread
Login to post to this thread

Just a starter... - Oct 5, 2004 at 9:05AM
Admin Avatar
Admin
AAPT
107 Posts

Judging from the poll results, there are plenty of people
with opinions about who won the first presedential debate...
let's keep things clean and above the waist!  Seriously,
discuss.  I know a lot of folks feel strongly about this,
and here's a great place to chat about it with other
students, maybe even change a mind or two.


Dodge this.

Replies to Just a starter...

Re: Just a starter... - Oct 05 2004 2:43PM
Alysson Avatar
Alysson
My chair
196 Posts

Don't get me wrong, homeland security is an important issue, but it's not going to sway my vote one way or the other.  But just in the presentation of the two candidates, Kerry was the better of the two.  Bush is the worst public speaker ::pause::  I have, uh, ::pause:: ever seen.  And stand up straight!  America needs a leader with good posture :)


-al


Re: Just a starter... - Oct 05 2004 3:37PM
DannyBoy Avatar
DannyBoy
Athens, Georgia
14 Posts

"Who won the debate" is such a broad question...
After the first debate I am still undecided, but Kerry does a point in his corner after the debate. Bush seemed to just repeat the same things over and over, take long pauses, and lay on the podium.
But of course a debate should not choose who the president is.
I'll keep watching and we'll see how I am swayed in the upcoming days.



Re: Just a starter... - Oct 05 2004 4:14PM
Dave Avatar
Dave
San Marcos, Texas
413 Posts

I think the previous two posters showed a lot of wisdom, and I will add that I feel the same way.  You should not choose a candidate on the basis of a debate.  Decide what issues are important to you, and pick a candidate whose stance on those issues is closest to yours.  That said, I will make the following observations on the debate.  I felt Kerry did a good job of stating his position clearly, and distinguishing his position from the President's.  He also clearly outlined his plan as far as foreign policy is concerned.  I felt the president did not address some of the things he and his administration have done during his first term, and did not clearly outline a plan for dealing with the situation in Iraq.  For that reason I would say Kerry came out on top.  I would also agree with Allyson that Kerry simply looked better.  He was attentive during the times his opponent was speaking, he did not stumble as much, and seemed better prepared.

Dave


Try not to become a man of success, but rather try to become a man of value -- Albert Einstein


Re: Just a starter... - Oct 06 2004 12:06PM
Asma
9 Posts

Not to be redundant or anything, but I think Kerry came out better.  Of course, you can't really say somebody won a debate, but there are some main things that every debator must do which Bush did not.

1. Dress neatly and appropriately
2. Address the concerns that were raised
3. Have more than one point to make.

Honestly, the man kept going on about how Kerry's a flipflopper even after Kerry disputed it.  He's the president; he should be a lot better at public speaking than this.



my two cents - Oct 06 2004 2:11PM
Admin Avatar
Admin
AAPT
107 Posts

The debate was more worthwhile than I had expected, although the amount of talking points and stale rhetoric (along with pure misinformation) provided by both sides was... staggering.

Kerry was stronger than I expected, Bush was, well, a bit out of it, really... I have a feeling the 'wrong war' phrase is one we're going to hear for a while, and I'm not sure Kerry should have said all that.  We'll see.  He certainly got a boost in the polls.


Dodge this.


Opinions on the final debate.... - Oct 14 2004 8:41AM
Admin Avatar
Admin
AAPT
107 Posts

Feel free to post thoughts about last night's debate here, as well....


Dodge this.


about the Nucleus - terms - privacy - faq - sitemap
ComPADRE NSF AAPT AIP SPS Sigma Pi Sigma NSDL